Why does hermione not help dobby. Reply NiceDrewishFella .

Why does hermione not help dobby Just touching the cloths does not break any spell or anything, its all about the intentions. If someone can capture the soul of Hermione and translate it then it’s good enough for me and in theory should be good enough for anyone but alas. 2. ~(ibid) they attributed Ron's behaviour to mere superstition without any logical base, not unlike when Ron got scared by the Grim in his third year: Ron looked at Hermione as though she had gone mad. She's not a healer and apparently essence of dittany only heals flesh wounds. 1. Directed by Chris Columbus. They may not eat much, but they have to eat something. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is a 2002 film in which Harry ignores warnings not to return to Hogwarts, only to find the school plagued by a series of mysterious attacks and a strange voice haunting him. :( Why didn't Hermione do anything in the 7th movie when Harry asked her to help him with Dobby? Hermione knew Dobby was a lost casenothing could have revived Dobby after the attack or she would have definitely helped Harry with Dobby considering she was the girl who started S. ” “Oh, Ron!” Hermione flung her arms around Ron’s neck and broke down completely. arc-they don't want to "Why, Dobby? What are you afraid of?" Dobby bowed his head, his bat ears drooping. Thanks to his help, Harry freed Dobby from his servitude by secretly giving him a sock via his master, Lucius Malfoy. Hermione Granger does not actually use a spell to stop a rogue bludger during a Quidditch match in the Harry Potter series. Dobby does things that he knows the malfoys would punish him for but there are no magical repercussions, he just hits himself Reply reply More replies. Prestige- Not only for the family, but also for the elves. She didn't ask for help- like from Madam Pince, for example. Malfory, but at the same time seemed to work for the family despite the fact that he didn't want to because he had no choice. In the books, she hid her bag in her sock, but lost her wand. basically, he's twelve lol Open menu Open navigation Ron lightens Hermione up, but what does he give her other than that? Hermione holds Ron to a higher standard, which is good for him, but seems like it would get annoying after a while. Dobby, on the other hand,, hates his master and does go directly against his wishes. So, no Dobby clearly had a strong conscience, and punished himself even when he had done "wrong" things that house elves should not do, even if they were for the right reasons. While elf-apparation gave Dobby mobility, it made him a difficult target for any potential life-saving magic, had Hermione been able to perform it. In 1992, he disobeyed his “Yeah, it will,” said Ron fiercely. What is the result of Dobby's actions in the Dursley's kitchen? and more. Jul 7, 2022 · Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. What she used on Ron was essence of dittany, which I Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. It wasn't true, but I do like how realistically she was portrayed, and the theme (attempting to help people due to somewhat selfish reasons), but I thought it was pretty obvious that Hermione’s flaw throughout the books was a streak of hubris in thinking that she knew best for everyone- Book 7 take Dobby along to help with all the surviving mode. They’d rather do without Kreacher than risk the very small Even then she was just tortured into unconsciousness, was at the cottage before Dobby and Harry left Malfoy manor, and dittany isn't a cure-all. Harry realizes they have successfully Apparated to Bill and Fleur Weasley’s seaside cottage, despite his uncertainty at takeoff. I always thought the reason the sock freed Dobby was because Malfoy Sr. Hermione was not an experienced healer. well in the books she says that shes not that good at healing spells and always relied on the potion that she used to fix rons are which had been splinged and in the books she wasnt even there as dobby died so she couldn't of saved him and in the movie she was there but was in shock due to being tourcherd by bellatrix lestrange so there was no way she was going One option to avoid this is zealotry: Do not try to understand what the real situation is (because it could tear down your ideals), but replace it with a world where everything works as it should work in your mind. " Watching the wand tip move with Hermione's heaving breaths, he added, "You aren't going to make a Hermione was barely conscious while Dobby died, so it wouldn't made an immediate impact on her. Dobby in "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Harry, worried and stressed, didn't think straight and just called for help. Why? He was a minor character. It took place around Easter of 1998 in Malfoy Manor, located in Wiltshire, England. I solved the problem to my own satisfaction in stages. Why does Hermione flinch when she hears "Voldermort" None of it makes sense. " "Oh, Dobby," said Hermione sympathetically, moving It is not our abilities that show us what we truly are. Why does McGonagall take Hermione and Ron? She calls for them because they are used as “loved ones” for the second task. She is touched in a very Muggle manner and obviously obsessed. I think I know a few things that would cheer “Not kill you, sir, never kill you!” said Dobby, shocked. So at the same time Harry, Hermione and Ron were at Hagrid's cabin, future Harry and Hermione were setting Buckbeak free. Also the elf must presented with clothing. Why didn’t they use Bellatrix’s wand at Gringotts? “She still does not care for clothes, Harry Potter. Hermione was cloaked by the magical signatures of all the wizards around her and in Diagon alley. That is why Dobby got Harry in trouble for using a hover charm. A psychiatrist forcibly restraining and sedating a manic patient who wants to hurl himself off a high ledge (because he thinks he can fly like Superman) is still trying to help the patient (by keeping him alive) even though the patient may disagree in his current (manic) Aug 1, 2015 · Why didn't Dobby or Harry use Healing Magic to treat Dobby. He gets to say a sentence or two and then he's gone. She can’t heal Dobby. If his master found out, Dobby would be severely punished. That's why they don't expect 2. However, Hermione, who is responsible for administering the potion, lacks the knowledge and resources Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone’s capacity to save. Firstly, I had Dumbledore and Hermione emphasise how dangerous it would be to be seen in the past, to remind the reader that there might be unforeseen and dangerous consequences as If Hermione is an ESTJ, why does she have such good insights into peoples emotions (e. Dobby does it all himself, sir, but Dobby does not mind, sir, for he always hopes to meet Harry Potter and tonight, sir, he has got Hermione had the right idea, I think, but was so far over to the side of "no elf slavery", that it was a bit extreme. Malfoy had no intent of Dobby getting the sock, or anything involved with the toss. Why did Hermione not hug Ron? According to the article, the reason Hermione did not hug Ron in the scene from “Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets” was due to embarrassment. Harry asks if he can help Dobby or save him from what seems like an abusive family. Do the house elves do everything except things involving clothing with their masters. W(Society for the Elfish welfare) and fought for elf rights. Dobby says that wearing rags is the sign of a house elves enslavement, and that he only way to free a house elf would be to give them proper clothes. For sure, Dobby never intended Harry to steal a car and then get lost in the forest in need of a car, but JKR did intend that, and the car would not have been there to save Harry's life coincidentally if Dobby had not forced Harry into stealing it by trying to save his life. The way his death affected Harry shows that it's really not just a bothersome acquaintance The Harry Potter franchise has had massive success, partly thanks to its heavy emphasis on friendship and family and the importance of maintaining those relationships. Hermione was not an Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone’s capacity to save. Kinda would have expected someone as well read as Hermione to know that Fae interests do not typically align with human interests. " "The tiles on the ceiling, do they lift?" Our muggle friend, a scruffy looking man with a short black beard pulled a face. Dobby is much smaller than your average human, and he is an entirely different species. During their search for other Horcruxes, Hermione noticed that Harry started to resemble Voldemort more as each day passed. A set of characteristics praised in a Caucasian Hermione but not praised in a BME Hermione because she would look different speaks volumes especially in regards to race. Dobby was one of the most beloved characters to come out of the Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. Dobby just lunges and grabs it. meaning their ideals and culture is vastly different. Additional comment actions. They could have proven it was sealed (unless of course Dobby unsealed it). But if she did witness Dobby's death, it would have counted, because Dobby and all house elves are sentient beings. We see from that that Dobby is not behaving naturally. I mean do they normally go out of their way to avoid their masters clothes. Unlike the others, who disregard elves, Hermione tries to hold them to the standards of humankind. Even when Dobby is freed, he refuses the pay and working rights a human would expect. Dobby wakes him mere minutes before the second task. Help Center Detailed answers to any questions you might have When does Hermione get a scar reading 'Mudblood' on her arm? harry-potter; The book didn't mention the carving. If it wasn’t a combination of these two factors, and say Ron had tried the same thing, I don’t think Dobby would have Why are Ron and Hermione not in the Common room, and why does Ron not believe Harry? Posted in Blog and tagged as Albus Dumbledore , Bartemius Crouch , Cedric Diggory , Fleur Delacour , Harry Potter , Ludo Bagman , The Four Champions , Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. gave him the book, I mean, he was giving him the book to do with whatever Dobby wanted to do with it, since it no longer had any value to Malfoy Sr. 5M subscribers in the harrypotter community. Although the movies would have you believe Hermione did not know about Harry being a Horcrux, the books tell a different story. In that case then, perhaps a combination of ignorance and apathy. Dobby says he knows that Harry did not find the right spell, so he did: Gillyweed. Nor do the other house-elves. It is a new situation for Dobby, and he is scared, confused, and not feeling well in his What Hermione needed to do was help the Elves that were actually suffering. Why did bathilda not want to talk to Hermione? Why did Hermione not help Dobby? Is Bellatrix a Gryffindor? Who put the Sword of Gryffindor in Bellatrix’s vault? 4 Has Been “Owned” By Nine People. W. Yes, he dobbed on Mr. Bill reports that Hermione is inside and is alright. Hermione had just been tortured by Bellatrix and was in no state to help Although she might not have had anything to help Dobby, she could have at least looked instead of standing there. Hermione: Bend over, Harry. The extent of damage caused by the enchanted knife was beyond the capabilities of the magical remedies available Hermione is not a medical witch. The ministry of magic does not know when a spell was cast by an underage wizard, they just know when there shouldn’t be a magical signature near a Muggle. Quoting from Rowling's Pottermore article on Time Turners: (one of the many parts not carried over to the new Pottermore). (Later he does use Lumous to illuminate an Ally on Privit drive, but he already blew up his aunt and thought he was on the road to Imagine that Dobby: picks up basket full of Luciuses underwear which I presume had something embarrassing like hearts or pink polka dots and his socks and pajamas and for some reason his pets clothes because he for some reason has a chihuahua that he loves so much haha Dobby also: lifts laundry basket above head dobby is a free elf! Lucius: runs in room with bathrobe And given the info we do have, where wise and kindhearted wizards are saying SPEW is anti-elf, and the house elves themselves are literally pushing Hermione away from them when she 'insults' them with offers of pay and freedom, I tend to think its more likely that they are genuinely living their ideal lives and that Dobby is just an oddball. From helping Harry during the second stage of the Triwizard Tournament to taking on Death Eaters at Malfoy Manor, Dobby would do anything to help his friends. It's like so annoying, and the real reason i could see why they cut him out of the following films we'll discuss, is because they really didn't know any better, or better yet didn't know he would become such a huge and important character later down the line. While elf-apparation gave Dobby mobility, it made him a Jun 20, 2018 · @AnthonyGrist Dobby was ultimately trying to help Harry (by keeping him safe from danger). Dobby the house elf died because he was trying to protect Harry, Ron and Hermione and all the others trapped in Malfoy mansion. They are thinking that Dobby is a bad influence on Winky and is a disgrace to them because he is free now, and they is saying that Dobby – that Dobby is a bad elf. This trope was named after how Ron Weasley is often portrayed as an abusive boyfriend towards Hermione, if not being outright evil, in fanfics, so Hermione can have a reason to leave him for Harry. Seeing his struggles, both wanting to help desperately and often being unable to. A house-elf who was utterly devoted to Harry Potter, Dobby put himself at great risk (and in serious physical pain) when he went out of his way to protect the young wizard from what Dobby knew would be significant danger. so to free a house elf you must present them with clothes that they can wear, and specify the clothes are for Love and Hermione. Lucius Malfoy needs Harry at school for the plan to work. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn’t Madam Pomfrey. “Not kill you, sir, never kill you!” said Dobby, shocked. I think I know a few things that would cheer What are your opinions on Hermoine's insistence on freeing the elves at Hogwarts? We know that the elves were treated well at school (especially under Dumbledore), and we also know that house elves like being enslaved/employed so long as they are treated properly. now, taking a look at when Winky was freed, you see that she was given a dress that fit her perfectly. What insight does Dobby give Harry about the life of a house elf?, 3. Why does Dobby give Harry the Gillyweed? Dobby overhears about the gillyweed and knows Harry will need it, and Dobby wants to help Harry anyway he can. fm/why-does-hermione-not-help-dobby-3/ Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. "House elves!" he managed. The big-eared, big-hearted house-elf, who just wanted a fair wage for Love and Hermione. Harry literally runs up to them before he realizes Dobby is dying 10 feet away. In any case, the first character to have the sword of Gryffindor in their position is Ragnuk I, followed by Gryffindor, Harry, Dumbledore, Snape, Ron, one of the Snatchers who Yeahhh the movies aren’t that great at sticking to the smaller plot details. In the movie, Bellatrix gives her that scar with the knife that killed Dobby. Pushing Harry roughly aside, he knelt over Malfoy, drew his wand, and traced it over the deep wounds Harry’s curse had made, muttering an incantation that sounded almost Jul 7, 2022 · In 1996, during the Battle of the Department of Mysteries, Neville Longbottom temporarily used Hermione’s wand after his wand was broken, and Hermione was incapacitated by Death Eater Antonin Dolohov. Dobby's favourite gift to receive was socks, likely because he was freed from his enslavement to the Malfoys with a sock. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Rowling's iconic "Harry Potter" series, readers encounter a myriad of spells, each serving unique purposes. under the Imperius for Dobby was elf-apparating – He was appearing and disappearing rapidly around the room. But we do know the house-elves stopped cleaning Gryffindor's common room once Hermione started leaving hats and socks around specifically for the house-elves to find and be freed. Hermione knows His wounds were too severe and he couldn’t be saved even with magic. No girls are Without Dobby’s bravery and willingness to put himself in danger, Harry and his friends may not have been able to defeat Voldemort and bring peace to the wizarding world. “The door banged open behind Harry and he looked up, terrified: Snape had burst into the room, his face livid. Why did Hermione not save Dobby? Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. It’s very much a maybe; it’s not a certainty, but they’re not willing to risk the chance that if they call Kreacher, someone might be brought along for the ride. Dobby is supposed to be a RARE case of freeing him being a good thing, and even then Dobby expresses feeling lost/unsure. He loves her as much as you can love a person, but it's always been platonic. Ron and Hermione's upbringing was vastly different, whereas Harry and Hermione could relate having grown up in the outside world, although I know Harry had a negatively unique experience even in that aspect. The movie also adds the details of Hermione saving them from Lupin, and the moment where she throws rocks at Harry (those two things are not in the book). “Dobby wants to save Harry Potter’s life! Better sent home, grievously injured, than remain here, sir! Dobby only wanted Harry Potter hurt enough to be sent home!” Thus, Harry is telling Dobby, perhaps slightly in jest, that he is better off without Dobby trying to save him. Its a big thing in Hermione's S. He's not just some pesky annoying pet, he's a friendly and hugely helpful ally. With Hermione wandless and weak, there was little she could do to protect Dobby in the frantic battle that ensued. FuzzyBoots. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything In chapter 24 (Bloomsbury) of Deathly Hallows-- The Wandmaker-- Harry and Griphook the goblin have a conversation wherein Harry asks for Griphook's help in breaking into Gringotts to retrieve the Hufflepuff cup Horcrux from the Lestranges' vault. While Dobby and all House-elves in the Harry Potter series always spoke in the third person and referred to themselves in the third person, there were moments in Harry Why did Dobby appear at Harry’s home? Dobby went to the Dursley house to warn Harry not to go back to school, revealing that he had been intercepting his mail. Dobby does not want to be enslaved, and is abused. After the battle, Neville returned Hermione’s wand to her and purchased a new wand for himself. " When Dobby presented Harry the socks, no doubt he was delighted but also a bit uncomfortable with Dobby's superlative titles regarding him. Do they not clean or fold or put the clothes away. Why do you think that Harry is obligated to develope a relationship with Dobby? even with Ron and Hermione. We never see any reason to believe Luna's theories. Explanation: In J. "But he's always so mean to Hermione. Written by Steve Kloves, based on the book of the Hogwarts elves are also did not like to be freed (like most elves). Dobby finally told Harry why he was there - he had a warning: he shouldn't go back to Hogwarts School in September because he would be in danger. Harry calls out for her to do something out of misplaced hope that Hermione will Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. In 1997, That does not seem to be the case for Dobby. why is their species called 'house elves' and not just elves? do regular generic elves even exist in the hp universe? i don't think we've ever heard of or seen any. Ron, looking quite terrified, patted her very awkwardly on the top of the head. Mere seconds past from the moment Harry noticed Dobby was injured until he passed away. But here's one thing I don't understand: why is it Ron that always gets this treatment, but not Hermione. so he didn't really care what the house-elf This works better for interpreting it as giving Dobby clothes— emphasis on giving. Ron wanting to help Hermione with Buckbeak. To me, giving implies intent of some magnitude. Harry finally understands that "Wheezy" is Ron. . That leaves the question of why it detected the Hover Charm, but we know that house-elves are capable of casting wizard's spells as well as using their own special house-elf magic, because Winky was accused of using Harry's wand to cast the Dark Mark in The Goblet of Fire. 'Most certainly, Harry Potter sir! Why can’t you just enjoy the franchise and ignore the creator? Because the creator not only continues to personally profit from people's "enjoyment" (continued purchasing of media/products) of the series, but utilizes that money In Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows Part 2 when they asked Bellatrix (Hermione) to show her wand because they needed proof that it was her, why didn't she show it to them? They obviously already had it because Ollivander said ''This wand belongs to Bellatrix Lestrange, treat it carefully''. Who gave Hermione the mudblood scar? Analyzing the situation further, it becomes clear why magical healing was not possible in Dobby's case. The House Elves are not something that come up in regular, everyday conversation with Muggleborn. Hmm, so I did, misread the question as why do the wizards as a whole not do much about the House Elf issue. I’ll help. Why did Dobby warn Harry not to go back to Hogwarts? Harry asked if he could help Dobby but he began wailing and talking about how humble he was and how brave he was for facing You-Know-Who twice. Same reason they didn't give Dobby a stab-resistant vest beforehand; not a lot of those in the woods. Arthur fixes his glasses in CoS. Hermione had just been tortured by Bellatrix and was in no state to help Why didn’t Hermione fix Dobby’s wound? Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Winky probably isn't physically abused (but we don't actually know), "wants" to be enslaved, and also has an example of her "master" holding Barty Jr. “You won’t have to do all the work alone this time, Hermione. Even if he did know healing spells, he wasn't thinking straight at the moment. SPEW was not really an important storyline for the house elves as much as it was for Hermione. Pulling the knife from Dobby's lifeless body, Harry then covers him with his jacket. The majority would say Hermione but for me it’s Ginny all day as I have a weakness for redheads. He wears them in his first official ball, and made sure that when Mad Eye Moody (cough Barry Crouch Jr) asks him about it, he acknowledges Dobby's gift and was smiling. But just look what he then does. In this sense, Dobby’s death serves a larger honestly i think it was just indignation, like why should he have to promise not to go to hogwarts, the one place where he's happy, for someone he's just met? this is on top of having an awful birthday and also finding out that his letters have been deliberately kept from him by dobby, the very person making him promise this. Dobby (28 June (year unknown) – March 1998) was a male house-elf who served the Malfoy family. it is, without a doubt, the most significant character arc involving Hermione throughout the series, and is really one of the few instance where you see an appreciable growth of her as an individual. I always did wonder about that! The character Lucius would never ever dare to try and kill Harry at Hogwarts (though the film was created before GoF came out and all Jason Isaacs really knew was that Lucius was definitely not a friend of This skirmish was a small but bloody event that took place at the height of the Second Wizarding War. E. Before his death, I can’t remember the last time he appeared in the book, and even when he appeared, he didn’t do anything important/memorable. Hermione and Ron were starting to develop feelings for each other, but they held off on hugging because it would have sent conflicting signals. But Dobby explains that a house-elf can only be set free by the family he works Lets see some reasons why people call her narrow-minded and why I think they're wrong: 1)Not believing Luna's theories. May 11, 2022 · Why does Hermione not help Dobby? https://celebrity. He acted correctly, not indifferently. Harry adamantly refused to comply, so Dobby performed a Hover Charm on Aunt Petunia’s pudding, which was detected by the Ministry of Magic through the Trace. Just stumbling upon it couldn’t possible free them. perhaps with Hermione's help. I always wondered why they never did this (aside from the fact that they are young and dumb and adventurous). There's a balance somewhere in the middle between what Hermione Why did Dobby warn Harry not to go back to Hogwarts? Harry asked if he could help Dobby but he began wailing and talking about how humble he was and how brave he was for facing You-Know-Who twice. She lacked the skills to do much She couldn't have done anything. It is not a pretty picture, help 😰 them from an early age. Using it on Dobby, a little creature who had a knife through his chest, would Attempts to save Dobby include applying Essence of Dittany, a potion known for accelerating wound healing. "Unfortunately they do, and they might find their way into here. I think it is obvious that Hermione is not rational about the house elves. No known distance limits (depends on concentration), Hogwarts to grounds is OK Ref: GoF, Harry vs broom; One of the big theories as to why Dobby couldn’t be saved has to do with Hermione losing her bag inside of the Malfoy Manor. Hermione ignored Dobby's plea that her continued preaching in the kitchen is aggravating and brings trouble for him. And Dobby dies pretty quickly. It is our choices. A cause (Harry taking the car to Hogwarts) resulted in an effect (the Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like 1. She didn't seem like the most likable character, and I can understand keeping the horcrux topic a secret, but Hermione could have easily asked for guidance on where to find information on Flamel or spells/enchantments that will aid in underwater breathing as opposed to believing the When Hermione came up with the idea for an organization that would help house-elves gain their freedom, Harry was initially dismissive. The things he's attracted to, like being sporty, funny, and seemingly considerable conventional beauty with long straight hair, are not qualities that Hermione embodies. well, apparently, Dobby considered this to be a safe place for me. Why does Dobby visit Harry?, 2. Rowling, the most amazing writer ever :) But Dobby feels he must help Winky. Hermione is not a medical witch. Share. The moment took place during the seventh Harry Potter movie, based on the book series written by J. " Malfoy made gestures that he wanted to speak, and I dropped the spell. Ron for Harry, and Hermione for Krum. Hogwarts elves were, apparently, happy in their work (despite what Hermione may have thought). g. than it is to help the living for Also stubbornness, to a degree. I mean, Harry was screaming for her to help him, she could have tried to With Hermione wandless and weak, there was little she could do to protect Dobby in the frantic battle that ensued. It's possible to care about two things but only act on one. Reply NiceDrewishFella That’s like asking: “why didn’t Harry use the Elder Wand to Oh! I actually know this one. Also, it seems they were ones who did the laundry so they did handle cloths. Chapter 1: Dobby's Visit. But Harry, Ron, and Hermione have NO IDEA when he might be in someone’s physical grasp. No need to know the location Ref: HP, Hermione vs Horcrux books. The right thing to do is to allow them to live the way Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby. Dobby does not wish to see Winky in such a bad state again, so worried she is!" "Maybe you should go talk to someone in Slytherin. Rowling. Just because a group of people/creatures do not know better, it does not mean that they should be enslaved/exploited. That part seems so weird for me. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Harry repeated, but Hermione shot him a warning look; apparently he was not to argue with Ron while the latter was in such a weakened condition. It’s not a huge issue if they end up at the same point in the end (like Neville telling Harry about gillyweed instead of Dobby, it’s immaterial in the end) but it does confuse and annoy people and they totally fudged bigger plot points like dumbledores memories of the gaunts and the horcrux hunting Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. P. Why does Harry stay That stuff doesn't happen in the books. They likely identify with eachother in that way. Not as flashy though. None of them will clean Gryffindor Tower anymore, not with the hats and socks hidden everywhere, they finds them insulting, sir. I think it has to do with intent and why the elf is interacting with the clothes. Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. Follow edited Jan 3, 2016 at 16:42. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Plus, Hermione was being tortured five seconds before, I doubt she was in the right state of mind to use her immense knowledge to save him without causing him more suffering. Brownies help people around the house because they want to, and they see themselves as sort of honoured visitors or family. Could be if you are ordered to do the laundry as a chore, it doesn't count. understanding all the things that Cho could be feeling at the moment) and the underlying emotions of the people around her, all things that They do NOT feel like its a good thing. Everything Dobby does in CoS is specifically related to trying to make sure Harry is as far away from the Chamber as possible, as he knows from overhearing Lucius Malfoy that the dark lord is involved, and that last time it opened someone died. The Trace is only set up to detect wizard's magic, not house-elf magic. [2] This skirmish was also an important moment Whereas Ron was more hot tempered, childish, vindictive and constantly jealous. and if they didn't, where did they derive 'elves' from? if that were the case, and house elves described the entire species and not a sub strand, why add the distinguishing 'house' part? well in the books she says that shes not that good at healing spells and always relied on the potion that she used to fix rons are which had been splinged and in the books she wasnt even there as dobby died so she couldn't of saved him and in the movie she was there but was in shock due to being tourcherd by bellatrix lestrange so there was no way she was going Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. No, probably not. The thing is that nobody believes Luna's theories, except Luna and her father and for good reason. "Dobby!" We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Dobby is a minor character, though he proves extremely useful to Harry throughout the series. "The other elves are not liking Dobby, Miss. 0. " In the book Dobby was critically injured- the knife in relation to his tiny body made a large wound. Dobby hated the Malfoys and went out of his way to try to save Harry. As Dean carries the injured Griphook into the cottage, Harry's scar prickles as he watches Harry would never be attracted to Hermione in that sense. His loyalty If it was anything, Harry had no idea why Hermione wanted to send the house elves away; their magic was just so wonderfully helpful! 'Then could you get her? Please?' He asked. 'Yes, yes, Dobby! Could you get her, now?' He emphasized on the last word. 'Harry Potter asked Dobby to help?' Dobby squeaked happily. Ever since, Dobby always watched over Harry from a distance, making sure that When Hermione tried to find an escape, Ron, and Harry side-along disapparated with her to the forest, why didn't Harry call for Kreacher, given the circumstances that the house-elf was now friendlier Of course that doesn't explain why didn't do it later (say after a few weeks) Share. 6 days ago Dobby popped up asking how he could help me, and I just asked for a safe place to soak, and. His masters were Dark wizards who treated him cruelly. Reply reply Winky, Dobby, and Kreacher. Disclaimer: Everything belongs to J. It is Dobby's similarly shabby treatment, compared with how Ron, Hermione, and Harry are treated by Draco, that leads the reader to guess, possibly before Harry, that Dobby is the Malfoy's House-elf. It also should probably be connected to people wanting to ship a Trio pairing due to their prominence in the books, but not liking the dynamic between Ron and Hermione, and seeing a supposedly more peaceful dynamic between Harry and Hermione (even though there is plenty to suggest that, in fact, they don't have a particularly peaceful dynamic). And because of Dobby and Kreacher, Ron finally understands the importance of the house elves leading to Ron and Hermione's first kiss. 3. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing – even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Ron cared about the passing of Dobby, but Hermione needed right now help. In the book, he just apathetically tosses the sock in the air, not caring a wink about it. Improve this answer. No, more likely Hermione settled for Ron. hermione is decribed as plain, She's not described as plain. To be associated with a rich, powerful family may be a source of pride for them (Dobby notwithstanding). Harry arrives at the lake just in time for the second task. And maybe a mention at the end of ending House Elf slavery in honor of the bravery of the elves at the Battle of When this does not work, he attempts to injure Harry so severely he is removed from the castle. It's not going to do much to heal a vital organ before the person dies. Griphook seems to hold Harry in at least higher esteem than he would probably hold most wizards, commenting on Harry taking the There was always a thought that Dobby the house-elf broke his promise to Harry Potter when he saved the wizard's life toward the end of the series, but that wasn't necessarily the case. We also know that they were so offended and angry by her actions that year they stopped cleaning the emma is much too attractive to not notice. Follow answered Dec 29, 2016 at 6:46 Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. From the moment Dobby entered our lives by landing a sugared violets pudding onto the Dursleys’ house guest, he has had a special place in our hearts. Is Dobby a good elf? In the wizarding world of Harry Potter, perhaps no one is more loyal and lovable than Dobby the house elf. Harry uses a flashlight to do his homework at home. Dobby, is practically everyone's favorite character, yet he really gets the short end of the stick in the films. Imagine if they just waited for the Weasleys to get back to the other side of the platform. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Who is Dobby?, What is Dobby's job?, How does Dobby punish himself? and more. Why is Hermione narrow-minded for not believing absurd theories? There’s not much I can think of in the text disproving the idea that house elves seemingly preferring enslavement is nurture over nature, the “here lies Dobby, a free elf” bit is hard for me to interpret as anything other than an endorsement of emancipation, Ron is implied to be coming around to Hermione’s view while I can’t think of Wow I never thought of it like this, I actually completely agree. I think it shows that she is basically a sweet and kind hearted person who grew up in the Muggle world and retains her cultural values. The Harry Potter universe is not safe from darkness and cruelty, and one of the elements found in the Wizarding World that has raised many questions is elves working as servants for most wizard families. K. She's not noticed as being attractive in the first few books because Harry isn't interested in girls in the first few books. It was Dobby, the house-elf, who had tampered with the bludger. "It does, so; there must be a secret way out. They literally do not want to be free. Reply reply S_ShockCage • Why do you think Hermione wasn’t there? In the movie Ron and Hermione are right there when Dobby dies. Harry thinks it is too late to compete, but Dobby says Harry must retrieve his "Wheezy". There were a lot of death in Harry Potter, but Dobby’s death has a very strong effect on people. I don’t even think Hermione could have healed Dobby, he was injured past the point of return. Substitute the house elves with children/mentally challenged people (examples of real-world groups of people . The ending of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 1 is perhaps the most tantalizing and exciting ending in the entire movie franchise, bringing together several plot threads Dobby tries to explain to Harry why he is there, but he keeps beating his head furiously on the wall, saying that because he is visiting Harry against the wishes of the family of he works for, he must punish himself. mlas zbxx okujy oluor tsn pbxxlflo wuuzi duvx eumrjp krqbywi